NO RECOVERY, NO FEE (855) 339-8879 FREE CONSULTATION

Judge Rules that Ex-Costco Lawyer isn’t Disqualified from Suing Costco


Judge Rules that Ex-Costco Lawyer isn’t Disqualified from Suing Costco sue compensation lawsuit personal injury sue attorney

U.S. District Judge R. Gary Klausner ruled that Downtown L.A. Law Group will not be disqualified from representing their plaintiff even though one of the current attorneys working at the firm used to work for the defendant.

Anthony Werbin, a lawyer at Downtown L.A. Law Group, previously worked at Manning & Kass, Elrod, Ramirez, Trester LLP; here, he worked over 1,000 hours on Costco’s legal matters, specifically he defended Costco in personal injury cases (at least one case) and served as a trial counsel on the company’s behalf. Werbin also attended a conference designed for the company’s California defense attorneys, in which they covered/discussed litigation and defense tools and strategies for personal injury cases.

Because of this, there was a motion to disqualify the plaintiff’s counsel. Costco’s attorneys argued that during Werbin’s time as an attorney for the company, Werbin “handled virtually every aspect of Costco’s personal injury lawsuits…[including] developing strategy, communicating with Costco employees [and insurance administrators]…reviewing confidential and privileged documents, preparing responses to discovery, preparing witnesses to testify at depositions and defending numerous depositions of Costco employees, and developing litigation strategy.” Based on this, Costco’s attorneys claimed that DTLA Law Group should not be allowed to represent the plaintiff – in Rodriguez v. Costco Wholesale Corporation et al. (a slip and fall case).

In an opposition filing, DTLA Law Group pushed back against Costco. Igor Fradkin, an attorney at the firm, stated that if Costco’s argument was “accepted in this matter, it would effectively prevent any former insurance defense attorney…from working as a plaintiff’s attorney in the future. If we carry this to its absurd conclusion, it would essentially keep an insurance defense attorney from ever switching firms and remaining a defense attorney.”

Ultimately, the judge ruled that Costco failed to establish a significant relationship between the cases that Werbin represented Costco and the current personal injury case that the law firm is handling (it is important to note that the personal injury case against Costco is being handled by two attorneys at DTLA Law Group, none of which are Werbin).

Understanding the Issue

The issue here is a conflict of interest specifically related to Anthony Werbin, who once was a defense attorney for Costco and is now a plaintiff’s attorney at the firm that is suing the company. In general, when a lawyer has a conflict of interest in a case, then the entire law firm is disqualified from the case (i.e., they cannot represent the plaintiff).

Of course, there are exceptions. A law firm can be disqualified from a case unless one of the following is true:

  • The conflict is personal and does not limit the representation in any way.
  • The conflict arises from the lawyer’s association with a prior firm/company, so the lawyer is timely screened from the case, the lawyer does not receive any fees from said case, written notice is provided to the former client, and the lawyer had no similar participation in the same matter at the prior firm.

Based on the details surrounding the judges ruling, the law firm wasn’t disqualified due to the latter point. Specifically, the lawyer did not participate in the same personal injury case while working with Costco because the personal injury case is a completely new case in which Werbin has never been involved.

belkin recall portable wireless charger product liability attorney incident compensation sue

Downtown L.A. Law Group

If this situation proves anything, it’s that Downtown L.A. Law Group is completely committed to their clients. No matter the obstacles that the team faces, they are ready to go above it all to effectively represent their clients and fight for their rights after their personal injury accidents.


Over $350 Million Recovered
for Our Clients

Learn More

YOU Deserve the Best
Free Case Review 24/7
You Don’t Pay unless we win
Call 855.385.2529


  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

By submitting this form, you agree to receive telephone calls and text messages at anytime, which include hours outside of business hours (8:00 am PST – 9:00 pm PST). This is so that we may reach you as soon as possible in order to consult on your potential case.

ultimate guide uber lyft accidents

Featured Lawyers


farid-medium

Farid Yaghoubtil, Esq.

sal-medium

Salar Hendizadeh, Esq.

Nina Sargsyan, Esq.

dan-medium

Daniel Azizi, Esq.

 

 

YOU Deserve the Best
Free Case Review 24/7
Call 855.339.8879

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
By submitting this form, you agree to receive telephone calls and text messages at anytime, which include hours outside of business hours (8:00 am PST – 9:00 pm PST). This is so that we may reach you as soon as possible in order to consult on your potential case.

Address:

LOS ANGELES OFFICE
4113 Clinton Ave,
Los Angeles, CA 90004
855-339-8879
info@downtownlalaw.com

BAKERSFIELD OFFICE
2005, Eye Street, Suite 4
Bakersfield, CA 93301
661-219-7455

MODESTO OFFICE
3430 Tully Road
Modesto, California 95350
209-353-4493

ORANGE COUNTY OFFICE
2372 Morse Ave.
Irvine, California 92614
949-627-8725

SAN DIEGO OFFICE
01 West Broadway
San Diego, California 92101
619-413-0161

OXNARD OFFICE
105 N Oxnard Blvd,
Oxnard, CA 93030
805-263-4423

SAN FRANCISCO OFFICE
1 Sansome St. Suite 3500-11
San Francisco, California 94104
650-651-5006

VENTURA OFFICE
701 E Santa Clara St
Ventura, California 95816
805-292-0367

INLAND EMPIRE OFFICE
7121 Magnolia Ave
Riverside, California 92504
909-340-3929

VICTORVILLE OFFICE
13782 Bear Valley Rd.
Victorville, California 92392
760-563-4384

FRESNO OFFICE
5588 N Palm Ave
Fresno, California 93704
559-556-0227

SAN FRANCISCO OFFICE
388 Market St #1300
San Francisco, California 94111
415-362-6079

SACRAMENTO OFFICE
1601 Alhambra Blvd
Sacramento, California 95816
916-931-1965

SAN FRANCISCO OFFICE
1 Sansome St. Suite 3500-11
San Francisco, California 94104
650-651-5006

MIAMI OFFICE
11900 Biscayne Blvd North
Miami, Florida 33154

EL PASO OFFICE
4600 Alabama St #C
El Paso, Texas 79930
(915) 201-3865


The information on this website is for general information purposes only. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship.
Follow us
© All Rights Reserved