NO RECOVERY, NO FEE
(855) 339-8879
FREE CONSULTATION

Why is Obama Care Unconstitutional?


Is Obamacare unconstitutional?The supreme court has made the decision to hear arguments by both side in the constitutionality Obama cares insurance mandate program.  Under the laws insurance mandate, every individual must purchase health insurance; failure to purchase insurance will lead to a fine (penalty) instituted by the federal government. The constitutionality of Obama care has less to do with the powers vested by the constitutional to the executive branch (president) then the power that are vested in the legislative branch (congress of the federal government.  Under the constitutional the federal government and by extension laws passes by the legislative branch of the federal government must be enumerated in the constitutional.  Under the 10 amendment of the bill of rights whatever powers not vested (enumerated) in the constitutional are the purview of the states. According to the Obama administration, congress has the power to institute an insurance mandate.  While this opposed to Obama care argue that the federal government (ie congressional legislative power) does not have the authority vested in the constitution to implement Obama cares insurance mandate.  In other words the congress cannot pass a law which forces individuals to purchase insurance. The two powers which are at issue here are (1) Congressional tax and spending power and more significantly (2) Congresses power over interstate commerce. Under the tax and spend power the federal government has the power to institute taxes on goods and services as it sees fit for the purpose of generating revenue.  One of the Obama administration s arguments for the constitutionality of the Obama cares insurance mandate is that the mandate and subsequent penalty of one does not purchase insurance constitute a tax.  If it is a tax then under congresses tax and spending power the law would pass constitutional muster.  However the Obama administration and supporters of Obama care have in the pas vociferously explained to the American people that the Insurance mandate was NOT a tax.  More so the law in no way states the this is a tax (ie for the purpose of generating revenue). If not a tax then the law would have to prove its constitutionality via the Commerce clause.  Congress has the power over interstate commerce.  Under the broad interpretation of the commerce clause, in place since the late 1930’s federal laws have been instituted to control vast and numerous aspects of our economy.   The key Supreme Court decision displaying the vast power of the federal government over our economy came in 1942.   In that case a farmer wanted to sell his wheat.  The federal government stated that the individual was not able to sell his wheat so that the price of wheat cold be stabilized.   The Supreme Court decided that the federal government has the power to PREVENT and individual from selling his goods in the market place since under the stream of commerce theory the selling of the wheat would have a substantial impact on interstate commerce. However, there has never been an instance where the federal government has forced an individual to purchase something in the marketplace.  In other words congress has the power to prevent you from doing an act witch has an effect on interstate commerce, however there has not been a case in which an individual was required (obligated) to purchase an item, ie purchasing of insurance because of Obama cares insurance mandate. By following this principle to the extreme one could contemplate the massive increase of the power of the federal government if it was constitutional for congress to pass a law which forced an individual to purchase an item (good or service).  In the future congress may force all citizens to purchase helmets while walking so as to prevent traumatic brain injury if something for tall building fell on your head. The key issue which will have to be resolved is whether the federal government has the power to compel individuals to purchase a product and face fine if that product is not purchased.

Over $350 Million Recovered
for Our Clients

Learn More

YOU Deserve the Best
Free Case Review 24/7
You Don’t Pay unless we win
Call 855.385.2529


  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

By submitting this form, you agree to receive telephone calls and text messages at anytime, which include hours outside of business hours (8:00 am PST – 9:00 pm PST). This is so that we may reach you as soon as possible in order to consult on your potential case.

ultimate guide uber lyft accidents

I had a previous attorney who failed me miserably. I reached to this Law group and it was the best decision I made. Very caring and understanding staff. Recommend this to law group to everyone.”

⋆⋆⋆⋆⋆

Lesley Portillo

Free Case Review 24/7
You Don’t Pay Unless You Win
Call 855.385.2529


  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
By submitting this form, you agree to receive telephone calls and text messages at anytime, which include hours outside of business hours (8:00 am PST – 9:00 pm PST). This is so that we may reach you as soon as possible in order to consult on your potential case.

Address:

4113 Clinton Ave,
Los Angeles, CA 90004
855-339-8879
info@downtownlalaw.com

BAKERSFIELD OFFICE
2005, Eye Street, Suite 4
Bakersfield, CA 93301
661-219-7455

MODESTO OFFICE
3430 Tully Road
Modesto, California 95350
209-353-4493

ORANGE COUNTY OFFICE
2372 Morse Ave.
Irvine, California 92614
949-627-8725

SAN DIEGO OFFICE
01 West Broadway
San Diego, California 92101
619-413-0161

VENTURA OFFICE
701 E Santa Clara St
Ventura, California 95816
805-292-0367

INLAND EMPIRE OFFICE
7121 Magnolia Ave
Riverside, California 92504
909-340-3929

VICTORVILLE OFFICE
13782 Bear Valley Rd.
Victorville, California 92392
760-563-4384

FRESNO OFFICE
5588 N Palm Ave
Fresno, California 93704
559-556-0227

SAN FRANCISCO OFFICE
388 Market St #1300
San Francisco, California 94111
415-362-6079

SACRAMENTO OFFICE
1601 Alhambra Blvd
Sacramento, California 95816
916-931-1965

SAN FRANCISCO OFFICE
1 Sansome St. Suite 3500-11
San Francisco, California 94104
650-651-5006

 


The information on this website is for general information purposes only. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship.
© All Rights Reserved
Follow us