Skip to main content
Only Pay If We Win
(855) 339-8879
FREE CONSULTATION
Our Headquarters have moved:
Our New Address is
612 S Broadway, Los Angeles, CA 90014

Wrongful Death Lawsuits Filed against Panera for Caffeinated Lemonade


Wrongful Death Lawsuits Filed against Panera for Caffeinated Lemonade sue lawyer attorney compensation incident liability

The restaurant chain Panera Bread is facing 2 lawsuits filed by families of individuals who died after consuming the company’s highly caffeinated Charged Lemonade. One lawsuit was recently filed by the family of David Brown, a 46-year-old man in Florida. His lawsuit follows an earlier case that was filed in October by family members of Sarah Katz, a 21-year-old University of Pennsylvania student.

According to an attorney for the families, Elizabeth Crawford, “We know that they would have not otherwise died and they not drank the lemonade.”

Brown passed away from cardiac arrest after having the lemonade 3 times during his visit to Panera Bread in Fleming Island, Florida. Katz died in September 2022 after consuming the beverage. Though she had a preexisting heart condition, it was “well managed with medication,” according to Crawford. She added that Katz had “long QT type one…when it’s managed with medication, there’s virtually 0% chance of a sudden death, unless there’s something else going on here.”

Panera Bread’s Charged Lemonade contains 390 milligrams of caffeine, which is about 10 times the caffeine content of a 12-oz can of Coke. And yet, “The drink is not marketed as such,” said Crawford. She contends that the beverage should be marketed as an energy drink based on the high caffeine content. The lawsuit also points out that the beverage was sold in the same area of the store as its non-caffeinated and low caffeine drinks, which can also mislead the consumer.

Wrongful Death Lawsuits Filed against Panera for Caffeinated Lemonade sue lawsuit lawyer attorney liability
Our Latest Verdicts and Settlements

$2.2 Million

Mass Tort Lawsuit

$2,287,495

Lead Poisoning

$54 Million

Sexual Abuse

$22 Million

Gym Accident

$2.5 Million

Slip and Fall

$2,100,000

Wage & Hour Claim

$1,900,000

Stairway Fall

$1,275,000

Slip & Fall at a Movie Theatre
Deaths Caused by Panera Bread’s Lemonade and other High Caffeine Beverages

Because of their popularity, people may be surprised to hear that caffeinated drinks can be fatal. Of course, it’s important to point out that these are rare instances, and it’s unlikely that you will be injured from downing an energy drink for a mid-afternoon boost.

However, deaths among individuals from sudden cardiac arrest have been noted in people that have consumed sports drinks, energy drinks, and other beverages with high amounts of caffeine. According to a article published by the National Library of Medicine, “these beverages could easily lead to severe cardiovascular events in young and older individuals who have underlying silent cardiovascular disease.”

The article also points out that these drinks contain ingredients that many people would not recognize as sources of caffeine. For example, “ingredients such as guarana, ginseng, and taurine have caffeine concentrations in different energy beverages that are equal to, or higher than those found in coffee.”

This is a key factor with cases involving Panera Bread Charged Lemonade, which contain gharana. Crawford said that the addition of this ingredient means that you are getting the same amount of caffeine from one 30-oz Charged Lemonade as you would from 3 Red Bulls.

There’s no disputing that this is an alarming amount of caffeine, even if you don’t have cardiovascular issues. In fact, the USDA recommends no more than 400 mg of caffeine per day for a healthy adult. That means one Charged Lemonade is almost an entire day’s worth of caffeine. When you look at it that way, Panera Bread clearly has a duty of care to disclose the possible health risks associated with this beverage.

Can I Sue Panera Bread for Wrongful Death?

Yes, you can sue Panera Bread for wrongful death if your spouse, child, or other family member died from drinking the company’s Charged Lemonade. However, there are certain elements you will need to prove in order to qualify for a wrongful death compensation claim.

For example, you must show that the decedent had a preexisting health condition, such as heart disease or high blood pressure. These individuals should avoid highly caffeinated drinks, which can increase their heart rate at dangerous levels. In addition, you must prove that your loved one’s death would not have occurred if they had not consumed the charged lemonade sold at Panera.

As for the company’s liability, we believe that its failure to clearly disclose the risks associated with these drinks makes them responsible if someone dies from drinking this lemonade. The company has enhanced their disclosures about this product and is in the process of lowering the caffeine content from 390 milligrams to 237 milligrams.

However, Panera is still responsible for injuries and deaths that occurred prior to these changes. As the victim of a corporation’s negligence, you have the right to seek compensation through a personal injury lawsuit. To discuss your available legal options, call the wrongful death lawsuit lawyers of DTLA Law Group.

Panera Lemonade Wrongful Death Lawsuit Case Values

The average value of a wrongful death lawsuit is between $500,000 and $1,000,000, though we have had our share of cases that were settled for $5,000,000 or more. To calculate a wrongful death settlement value, there are many factors we need to examine. Primarily, we need to determine the economic and non-economic damages you are eligible to receive, which may include:

  • Funeral costs
  • Medical bills up until the victim’s death
  • Pain and suffering
  • Mental anguish
  • Loss of consortium
  • Loss of expected income / savings / benefits
  • Cost of hiring an attorney

The decedent’s age and their role in your life, as well as the degree of negligence by the defendant also have a big impact on case values. Ultimately, you must speak with an experienced California wrongful death lawyer to figure out what your lawsuit is worth.

How Long Does it Take to Settle a Wrongful Death Lawsuit?

On average, it takes 1 to 2 years to settle a wrongful death lawsuit if we are able to negotiate a settlement with Panera Bread’s insurance company. If we need to take your case to trial, settling a Charged Lemonade wrongful death case may be settled in 3 to 4 years. It should be noted that most cases are settled out of court, even if a trial date is scheduled. Based on Panera Bread’s willingness to admit liability, it’s possible that a settlement will be reached within 6 months. However, we find that the vast majority of cases require at least 12 months before both sides agree on the amount of compensation for a wrongful death lawsuit.

Wrongful Death Lawsuits Filed against Panera for Caffeinated Lemonade lawsuit liability compensation lawyer attorney sue
What is the Deadline to File a Claim for Wrongful Death?

A lawsuit for wrongful death must be filed within 2 years from the date of the victim’s death. To ensure that your claim is filed within the statute of limitations under California laws, contact our law firm right away. If you do not initiate a claim within 2 years of your loved one’s passing, you will permanently lose the right to sue Panera Bread for monetary damages. Our lawyers are ready to take immediate action on your behalf, so please call to schedule a free consultation.

Contact a Death by Negligence Lawsuit Attorney

The pain of losing a spouse or member of your family can’t be erased by money, but surviving loved ones should not have to struggle with medical bills, funeral costs, and other expenses that are left behind by a tragic death. Aside from covering these losses, compensation is a way to hold companies responsible when someone is harmed as a result of negligence.

If your family member died from consuming Panera Bread’s Charged Lemonade, please allow us to advise you of your rights during a free case evaluation. If you are eligible for a lawsuit against the restaurant, a wrongful death attorney will take immediate action on your case at no upfront cost. Legal fees are paid by Panera Bread as long as we win your lawsuit, so there’s no cost to you in the event we fail to recover your settlement.

We look forward to representing your interests and fighting for the justice you deserve.


Over $1 BILLION Recovered
for Our Clients
Learn More

YOU Deserve the Best

Free Case Review 24/7
You Don’t Pay unless we win
Call (855) 339-8879

ultimate guide uber lyft accidents